This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in the Journal of Medical Internet Research, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on http://www.jmir.org/, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.
In this paper we propose the idea that Artificial intelligence (AI) is ushering in a new era of “Earlier Medicine,” which is a predictive approach for disease prevention based on AI modeling and big data. The flourishing health care technological landscape is showing great potential—from diagnosis and prescription automation to the early detection of disease through efficient and cost-effective patient data screening tools that benefit from the predictive capabilities of AI. Monitoring the trajectories of both in- and outpatients has proven to be a task AI can perform to a reliable degree. Predictions can be a significant advantage to health care if they are accurate, prompt, and can be personalized and acted upon efficiently. This is where AI plays a crucial role in “Earlier Medicine” implementation.
artificial intelligencedigital healtheHealthhealth care technologymedical innovationshealth information technologyadvanced care systems
In this paper we propose the idea that artificial intelligence (AI) is ushering in a new era of “Earlier Medicine.” Advanced digital health solutions play a significant role in improving health care by enabling accurate diagnosis, prescription automation, and early prediction of diseases with potential AI capabilities [1,2]. “Earlier Medicine” refers to a temporally predictive and proactive approach to individualized health enabled by innovative AI modeling plus longitudinal/personal health big data. It calls on medical practice to not just react or manage present situations but also medical events of the foreseeable future. Such an approach will save money, lives, and our health care ecosystem from inefficiencies and disintegration.
Monitoring the trajectories of both in- and outpatients has proven to be a task AI can perform reliably [3]. Predictive tools present a considerable advantage to medicine if they are accurate, prompt, customizable, and actionable. This is where AI plays a crucial role in “Earlier Medicine” implementation. In the late 1940s, Leavell and Clark [4] proposed three levels of prevention: primary, secondary, and tertiary. The term “primary prevention” was used to describe “measures applicable to a particular disease or group of diseases to intercept the causes of disease before they involve man” [4]. It is important to note, however, that the concept of prevention has evolved with time. Leavell and Clark's definition is disease-oriented, but the application of prevention overall extends beyond medical problems and addresses other societal concerns. Through prevention, we can create a society that fosters good health to improve the quality of care [5].
In the 1970s, Schwartz [6] speculated that by the year 2000, a sizeable amount of the thought process involved in medicine could be augmented by a division of AI known as expert systems. Recently, Topol [7] proposed that new technologies will improve the precision and accuracy of diagnosis and in doing so will enhance treatment selection. In the last 2 years, the World Health Organization (WHO) has been reviewing evidence on digital technologies from consulting experts around the world in order to assemble recommendations on ways such tools can be used for maximum impact on health care. In 2018, governments unanimously adopted a World Health Assembly resolution, calling on the WHO to develop a global digital health strategy to support national efforts to achieve universal health coverage [8]. The United States Food and Drug Administration has been proposing ways to establish greater oversight over this rapidly evolving segment of AI products to regulate these systems whose performance constantly change based on exposure to new patient data in different clinical settings [9]. Keeping these initiatives in mind, the saying, “prevention is better than cure” can be realized in a way like never before due to the advent of AI for “Earlier Medicine.” This brings us to propose the following levels of prevention—Actionable, Accurate, Timely, and Individualized (Figure 1).
Artificial intelligence (AI) for "Earlier Medicine" with primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention levels.
First, we propose that primary prevention using AI should be targeted at those who are well. In the case of screening all healthy individuals for risk of disease, AI can be used for earlier rather than early detection for risk reduction. However, current screening protocols are oversimplified and suffer from low compliance. More robust models are needed, for example, for the risk prediction for nonmelanoma skin cancer [10]. Screening procedures are often the first step leading to early interventions that are more cost-effective than intervening once symptoms appear. In United States, positive results from screening mammograms were of little benefit; they resulted in increases to costs, and did little to nothing to ensure quality of life and decrease mortality rate [11]. Early detection serves little purpose for patients with an illness. We believe that society would benefit more from increased precision in the selection of groups for screening with AI-based earlier risk reduction using AI prediction technology. Other examples of the possible use of AI prediction technology is in the diagnosis of some forms of melanoma from an atypical mole such as cutaneous pigmented lesion screening, using smartphone‐generated images and clinical information simultaneously [12]. The incorporation of genomic information in electronic health records as part of one’s personalized treatment will drive the greater use of AI in primary prevention [13].
Secondly, we advocate that “Earlier Medicine” for secondary prevention is just as crucial. For a patient who is at risk of or suffering from a disease, AI can compute a management plan tailored to the patient’s individual needs. Secondary prevention AI includes recurrence prediction (eg, predicting non–ST-elevation myocardial infarction for patients with chest pain [14]).
Third, “Earlier Medicine” for tertiary prevention focuses on the deterrence of consequences of disease such as complications and disability. It also focuses on the overall improvement of quality of life through AI-based earlier interventions. Most countries are experiencing increases in the proportion of older people that comprise their population. It is estimated that by 2030, around 22% of the world’s population will be over 60 years of age [15]. There is an increasing prevalence of chronic disease in this age bracket globally and assisted daily living levels vary among regions [16,17]. Current health care systems that deal with this leave much to be desired in terms of long-term care, palliative care, and the expenses needed to maintain the system. Once a developed disease has been treated during its acute clinical phase, tertiary prevention seeks to soften the impact caused by the disease and potential complications on the patient's function, longevity, and quality of life. Tertiary prevention can include modifying risk factors. In cases where the condition is not reversible, tertiary prevention focuses on rehabilitation, assisting the patient to accommodate to disability [18]. For example, “Earlier Medicine” for tertiary prevention based on AI-computed individualized risk would help to prevent falls at home by 90% while reducing at least 10% of the dependent cost [19]. The key goal of tertiary prevention is to enhance quality of life by focusing on home health care services for either a short or long period as a result of illness, impaired health, old age, or other factors [20,21].
We earnestly believe that AI for “Earlier Medicine” will not only transform the practice of medicine but also radically reshape health care around the world. Harnessing the power of digital technologies is essential for achieving universal health coverage and to reviving humane medical practices for improving the quality of care [22]. The idea of prevention has evolved over the years from primary to tertiary and from a doctor-driven to patient-centered care model. AI for “Earlier Medicine” can serve as virtual medical assistants for clinicians, allowing for the resurgence of empathy-based care [23].
AbbreviationsAI
artificial intelligence
WHO
World Health Organization
LAC is funded by the National Institutes of Health through NIBIB R01 EB017205.
None declared.
AhujaAbhimanyu SThe impact of artificial intelligence in medicine on the future role of the physicianPeerJ2019107e770210.7717/peerj.7702315923467702PMC6779111KukafkaRDigital Health Consumers on the Road to the FutureJ Med Internet Res201911212111e1635910.2196/1635931750835v21i11e16359PMC6895867ParrecoJHidalgoAParksJJKozolRRattanRUsing artificial intelligence to predict prolonged mechanical ventilation and tracheostomy placementJ Surg Res20180822817918710.1016/j.jss.2018.03.02829907209S0022-4804(18)30193-8TopFHPreventive Medicine for the Doctor in His Community: An Epidemiologic ApproachArch Intern Med19590101103116410.1001/archinte.1959.00270010170027Glossary of terms used in the "Health for All" series, no. 1-8World Health Organization19842020-07-02https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/39565SchwartzWBMedicine and the ComputerN Engl J Med19701203283231257126410.1056/nejm197012032832305TopolEDeep Medicine: How Artificial Intelligence Can Make Healthcare Human Again20190312UKHachetteSeventy-first World Health Assembly update, 25 MayWorld Health Organization201805252020-07-02https://www.who.int/news-room/detail/25-05-2018-seventy-first-world-health-assembly-update-25-mayProposed regulatory framework for modifications to artificial intelligence/machine learning (AI/ML)-based software as a medical device (SAMD): discussion paper and request for feedbackUnited States Food and Drug Administration20192020-07-02https://www.fda.gov/files/medical%20devices/published/US-FDA-Artificial-Intelligence-and-Machine-Learning-Discussion-Paper.pdfWangHWangYLiangCLiYAssessment of Deep Learning Using Nonimaging Information and Sequential Medical Records to Develop a Prediction Model for Nonmelanoma Skin CancerJAMA Dermatol2019090415511127710.1001/jamadermatol.2019.2335314834372749356PMC6727683MorrisEFeigSADrexlerMLehmanCImplications of Overdiagnosis: Impact on Screening Mammography PracticesPopul Health Manag20150918 Suppl 1S1S31110.1089/pop.2015.29023.mor26414384PMC4589101ChinYHouZ YLeeM YChuH MWangH HLinY TGittinAChienS CNguyenP ALiL CChangT HLiY C JA patient-oriented, general-practitioner-level, deep-learning-based cutaneous pigmented lesion risk classifier on a smartphoneBr J Dermatol2020060118261498150010.1111/bjd.1885931907926HazinRBrothersKBMalinBAKoenigBASandersonSCRothsteinMAWilliamsMSClaytonEWKulloIJEthical, legal, and social implications of incorporating genomic information into electronic health recordsGenet Med201310121510810610.1038/gim.2013.11724030434gim2013117PMC3926430WuCHsuWIslamMMPolyTNYangHNguyenPWangYLiYAn artificial intelligence approach to early predict non-ST-elevation myocardial infarction patients with chest painComput Methods Programs Biomed20190517310911710.1016/j.cmpb.2019.01.01331046985S0169-2607(18)31693-6Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population DivisionWorld Population Ageing 201920192020-07-02New York, NYUnited Nationshttps://www.un.org/en/development/desa/population/publications/pdf/ageing/WorldPopulationAgeing2019-Highlights.pdfScheel-HinckeLLMöllerSörenLindahl-JacobsenRJeuneBAhrenfeldtLJCross-national comparison of sex differences in ADL and IADL in Europe: findings from SHAREEur J Ageing20200314171697910.1007/s10433-019-00524-y32158373524PMC7040124KuoHLinKLanCLiIActivities of daily living trajectories among institutionalised older adults: A prospective studyJ Clin Nurs201712232623-244756476710.1111/jocn.1382828334483CattelaniLPalumboPPalmeriniLBandinelliSBeckerCChesaniFChiariLFRAT-up, a Web-based fall-risk assessment tool for elderly people living in the communityJ Med Internet Res20150218172e4110.2196/jmir.406425693419v17i2e41PMC4376110GomezFCurcioCLBrennan-OlsenSLBoersmaDPhuSVogrinSSuriyaarachchiPDuqueGEffects of the falls and fractures clinic as an integrated multidisciplinary model of care in Australia: a pre-post studyBMJ Open2019072997e02701310.1136/bmjopen-2018-02701331362962bmjopen-2018-027013PMC6678026KangHHanJKwonGHAn Ecological Approach to Smart Homes for Health Care Services: Conceptual Framework of a Smart Servicescape WheelJMIR Mhealth Uhealth2019020872e1242510.2196/1242530735145v7i2e12425PMC6384540WillisMDuckworthPCoulterAMeyerETOsborneMThe Future of Health Care: Protocol for Measuring the Potential of Task Automation Grounded in the National Health Service Primary Care SystemJMIR Res Protoc2019040984e1123210.2196/1123230964437v8i4e11232PMC6477572RajkomarADeanJKohaneIMachine Learning in MedicineN Engl J Med20190404380141347135810.1056/nejmra1814259ShenJZhangCJPJiangBChenJSongJLiuZHeZWongSYFangPMingWArtificial Intelligence Versus Clinicians in Disease Diagnosis: Systematic ReviewJMIR Med Inform2019081673e1001010.2196/1001031420959v7i3e10010PMC6716335